Why Running in the Right Shoe Matters

March 26, 2015

Did you know that approximately 27 million adults will experience a running-related injury this year, and that those injuries will result in more than $35 billion in direct costs?*

With up to 70 percent of recreational and competitive long distance runners estimated to sustain an overuse injury this year, the chances are high that any of us could be one of those sidelined runners.*

During the past few weeks, I’ve been studying running mechanics, gait and injury prevention as continuing education for my marathon coaching. Abnormal running mechanics are believed to be one of the most often causes of running-related injuries. The shoes we wear and our foot structure play an important role in injury prevention.* For newer runners, it can be tempting to pick a shoe based on how it looks versus how it fits. It can even be tempting to make a choice based on price. That’s a recipe for disaster.

Just as Cinderella’s dainty little foot is the only one to perfectly fit into that infamous glass slipper, how do we know if we’re running in the right shoes that will make the magic happen?

Road Runner Sports’ Shoe Dog® customized fitting analysis may be the solution.

Road Runner Sports Shoe Dog Fitting Review on runladylike.com
Road Runner Sports Shoe Dog fitting process on runladylike.com

For the past three years, I’ve been running almost exclusively in the Brooks Running PureCadence (you can read my review of the latest model here). Thankfully, I’ve remained injury-free throughout this entire period. As a result, it has been ages since I’ve had a professional shoe fitting and gait analysis. (If it ain’t broke, don’t fix it, right? Well … )

I decided it was time to take a look at my footwear selection, as well as test myself in a number of different shoes to better understand how they affect me and my long-term running safety.

Road Runner Sports recently invited me to experience a custom fitting at my local store to learn more about my feet and stride. I jumped at the chance and was excited about the visit, but I must admit I was a little skeptical.

I’ve always thought of Road Runner Sports as a great store with a great selection of running gear, but not one I would ever go to for a professional fitting. My perception was that because they are a large chain, their staff aren’t as knowledgeable. I had one experience years ago with someone I didn’t think knew much about running, and ever since I’ve stuck to locally owned specialty stores in Atlanta, which are at no shortage here.

My mind was completely changed this past weekend.

Road Runner Sports did the most comprehensive shoe fitting I’ve ever experienced. As a running science geek, I was blown away by the technology and impressed by the process. Of course, I requested to try on all the different Brooks Running shoes across the stability and neutral categories (and I even sold a fellow customer a pair of Brooks Ghosts while I was there. Ha!).

How does the Road Runner Sports Shoe Dog custom fitting process work?

First, I answered some questions about my current running, like what kind of terrain I run on, how many miles I run a week and my history with injuries.

Next, I stood on a foot pad that assessed how I distribute my weight.

Road Runner Sports Shoe Dog fitting review on runladylike.com
Road Runner Sports Shoe Dog fitting review

I was surprised to learn that about 63 percent of my weight was on my right foot and the other 37 was on my left. I am right-side dominant, including on the bike, so this was a good reminder that I need to work on strengthening my left side further. It also showed that I have high arches.

Next, I ran barefoot on the treadmill so my shoe fitting expert Sean could assess my foot mechanics and pronation (essentially how your ankle, forefoot and heel react when your foot makes contact with the ground) at my strike, mid-stance and toe-off points.

Road Runner Sports Shoe Dog fitting review on runladylike.com
Road Runner Sports Shoe Dog fitting process on runladylike.com
Road Runner Sports Shoe Dog fitting process on runladylike.com

All the other places I’ve ever been tested had me run in shoes. I really liked running barefoot to see my pure mechanics without any alteration.

Road Runner Sports Shoe Dog fitting process on runladylike.com

Sean and I then looked at my foot mechanics on the screen in slow motion so I could see and better understand my issues.

It was no surprise to me that I’m a slight over-pronator, meaning I need some stability in my shoes. My ankle rolls inward when my foot strikes the ground, but my toe-off is fairly straight.

Next up, Sean made me some handcrafted, custom-made insoles. I am not a big fan of orthotics unless you are experiencing a specific overuse injury, but these are really interesting. (Again, my perception changed.) You stand on this machine, they are custom heated and created to fit the exact bottom of your foot. They retail at $71 for Road Runner Sports VIPs. They make them for everyone as part of the fit process, but you aren’t under any obligation to purchase them.

Road Runner Sports Shoe Dog fitting process on runladylike.com
Road Runner Sports Shoe Dog fitting review on runladylike.com

Finally, it was time to try on shoes. Bring on the motherload of Brooks Running shoes!

Road Runner Sports Shoe Dog fitting review on runladylike.com

Sean told me that if he didn’t know I preferred Brooks, he also would have had me try on some Asics, Nike and Saucony. I did try on a pair of the Saucony Mirage which are the closest thing to the Brooks PureCadence. Unfortunately, all of their stores across the country were out of the PureCadence in most sizes. This really bummed me out, but it enabled me to be open to considering some other options.

The coolest part of the entire fitting process is that you can watch yourself on the screen in multiple shoes at the same time to really see which is best for you.

Road Runner Sports Shoe Dog fitting analysis on runladylike.com

I ran in the Brooks Ravenna (stability category), the Brooks PureFlow 4s with my insoles (neutral shoes with slight stability from the inserts) and the Saucony Mirage (lightweight stability shoe). When compared side-by-side, I was shocked that the PureFlows with the Road Runner Sports insoles were nearly perfect and much better than the other two options. (Mind changed again!)

Road Runner Sports Shoe Dog fitting review on runladylike.com
Road Runner Sports Shoe Dog review on runladylike.com

I also really like that they have a 90-day no questions asked guarantee in which you can return your shoes. This enables me to come back to the store when they have their PureCadence in and decide if I want to keep my PureFlows with inserts or get the PureCadence instead. I’m also a big fan of their store-brand socks after running in them several times this week.

Road Runner Sports Shoe Dog fitting review on runladylike.com

Overall, it was an exceptional experience and one I would highly recommend. Call in advance to learn a little bit more about the shoe fitting experts at the Road Runner Sports near you so you’re comfortable with your expert. Perhaps schedule an appointment with one of the managers or coaches who fits your needs and experience level.

Road Runner Sports Shoe Dog review on runladylike.com

Be sure to stop by runladylike.com every week for the next three weeks as I’m teaming up with Road Runner Sports to share more on running form and mechanics. Next month, I’ll also be giving away this complete experience to one lucky winner, including a Road Runner Sports Shoe Dog custom fitting, shoes, custom insoles and socks. Don’t miss a post!

Happy running!

*The data cited in this post is from the text Running Mechanics and Gait Analysis by Reed Ferber and Shari Macdonald. They cite numerous studies from across America and around the world as part of their findings. All of those citations can be found in their text and references section.

Road Runner Sports provided me with a custom fitting experience, pair of shoes, socks, custom insoles and gift card for free in exchange for an honest review about their fit process. This is part of their Running Buddy blogger team. No benefits I receive from a company ever influence my review or what I write about the products/experience in any way. I only share things here on runladylike.com that I would feel good about for myself, my closest running friends and YOU! If you ever have a negative experience with anything I write about on runladylike.com, feel free to send me an email at runladylike@gmail.com.

Have you been professionally fit for running shoes lately? Did you experience any surprises? If you’ve ever been through the Road Runner Sports Shoe Dog fitting process, what did you think about the experience?

Comments

Runners Connect

Jesica, thanks for the in-depth analysis. It is important that you are taking your injury prevention so seriously, and so many runners are out there in the wrong shoes that are a big contributing factor to their injuries. One note, it is important you do find a specialist who does understand this, as some running stores do not train their staff, and runners can be in a worse situation than they were in before. Did you listen to our podcast about this yet? You will probably enjoy it http://runnersconnect.net/rc43 Would love to hear your thoughts!

rUnladylike

Thanks so much for sharing your podcast with me. I have listened to several (love listening to them in the car while driving!), but haven’t gotten to this one yet. Will add it to my list for sure! And I couldn’t agree more about fit specialists. It is easy to tell if someone doesn’t know what they are talking about. At Road Runner Sports, I was fit by the store manager who was also a long-time high school running coach from Oregon and who ran in college. That was really important to me to know that I was working with someone who had a lot of experience and understood what he was doing. Additionally, being able to see first hand my mechanics on screen from the back also equipped me with the information I needed to make the best selection. Thanks again for all the great content you guys produce for us! xo

Mary

I was fitted in January, and it was the first time I had the chance to be videoed and really see the difference in my gait with each shoe. I was really surprised when we saw that the best shoe for me was the Brooks Adrenaline – with my blue Super Feet inserts. I need A LOT more support than I realized! Having started in a Ghost, then a Ravenna, then a Ravenna with inserts, and now the Adrenaline (w/ inserts) I feel better than ever. None of the issues that would pop up before. Really impressed with the shop. I am so glad I took the time to get it done properly!

Mary

Not a Road Runners shop, but a small independent one with great technology!

Kalie

I went out of town to get professionally fit for shoes in the Saucony Stride Lab at Boulder Running Company last summer. I’d been fitted for shoes at my local running store when I started running and a couple times buying shoes. They told me I was a neutral runner. Found out from the Stride Lab that I actually pronate and needed something more supportive than the Glycerins I had been loyal to. They gave me a few options to try. Currently, I run in the Brooks Adrenaline but I also have a pair of Asics Kayanos and Saucony Omnis. Still not sure what shoe I like best but since switching from neutral to more support I get significantly less blisters and foot pain! They also noticed I have weak glutes so I’ve used that knowledge to strength train more. I would like to try a Road Runner Sports fitting though. The Stride Lab still had me in shoes and it’d be interesting to know what I do barefoot:)

rUnladylike

That experience sounds AMAZING Kalie! Doing something like that is definitely on my to-do list. Thanks for sharing! Glad that you’re feeling better in stability shoes. Have you ever tried the Brooks PureCadence? They are the lightweight stability shoe but you may need more if the Adrenaline are working. They are my favs. I ran my first two marathons in Adrenaline 🙂 Happy running! xo

Kalie

It was really in depth and the treadmill measured the force of my feet hitting the ground as I ran. Their cameras captured me running at all views – even birdseye! They also recorded me trying different shoes so I could see how they worked for me (similar to what it looks like you did). Definitely recommend them. My Adrenaline 14s are nearing retirement so I am thinking of seeing if I can get away with something like the PureCadence. I’ve had great luck with the Adrenalines but they are a lot of shoe for speed work and even 5ks as I work to get faster.

kristin | W [H] A T C H

woah! i’ve had a custom fit, but nothing like this. i love that they do a gait analysis in each of the different shoes — that’s brilliant. i would be really interested in seeking out a fitting like this because i just buy the same shoe generation after generation. fascinating post.

Tricia

I’ve been a a Road Runner fan for a while and done a fitting there. I became a big fan of their socks and pretty much run exclusively in them. I also like their RR brand tops

Audrey

What a great write up for RR! My dads always been a VIP there but we still prefer the BPRC- for the reasons you said. I am in Atlanta for a CLE so I’m going to sneak out and check out the RR store again. I’ve been dying to try the cadence or flows (I’m a Ravenna runner). Do you think you’d prefer the cadence over the flows without inserts? Thanks for bringing such great info to your readers!!

rUnladylike

Hi Audrey! I also really like BPRC 🙂 I used to be a Ravenna runner and they just aren’t the right shoes for me. I would go for shoes without inserts first. Have them test you out in both and watch side by side so you can really see. I have loved my transition from Ravenna to Cadence, but know everyone is different. Keep me posted if you try them out on what you think. If you go to Road Runner, go to the Buckhead store on Roswell Road and schedule an appointment with Sean or Suzie. They are the managers and are very experienced runners. xoxo

Audrey

Thank you Jesica! I will let you know! 🙂

Lex @ Flecksoflex

I did my first (and only) ever shoe fitting at the Road Runner in Rockville, MD last year. It was amazing! I too enjoyed the experience of running barefoot on the treadmill, and it was so cool to see my running in action. Thanks for sharing this post!

rUnladylike

I’m so glad to hear you had a good experience Lex! That’s great. It was my first time running barefoot during an analysis 🙂 xo

Jill

It is funny, I love the same shoes as you and I am a pronator and had a foot crush injury, so I did the custom fitting and the insoles helped me a lot. The place seems helpful and gave me a ball to roll my foot injury over to stretch it. Its all the stuff my physical therapy said I needed like custom insoles and the ball.

I like all the same shoes as you like the purecadence 4 and I tried pureflow 4 but the made me hurt in my achilles after 2 days of running 2 and 3 miles each day in them. That was before the insole.

I really liked mirage 5 and bought a pair of fastwitch sauconys and asic gt 2000 3 trail runners. All good if you have ankle and pronation issues and an injury. I am happy to see someone else like the roadrunner experience amd have similar injuries and use siilar shoes. I feel on the right track lol. Thanks for your post.